We’ve Broken Out The “Jump To Conclusions” Mat Again

Richard Collier is recovering from surgery after being shot outside a club waiting to meet up with some women he saw in a club. That’s it. And yet, the AP copy appearing on ESPN is doing the same goddamn thing ti and everyone else did when Sean Taylor got killed trying to defend his girlfriend and daughter — for some reason it feels compelled ot put his past transgressions on display while he lies in critical condition.  There are the versions on ESPN and on Yahoo, I haven’t been able to locate the mentions on the AP Yahoo copy. But it has fuck all to do with whatever Collier has done in the past or what other Jaguars are accused of.

The shooting also was the latest in a long list of off-the-field troubles for the Jaguars. [Fred] Taylor was charged with disorderly conduct over the weekend. Receiver Matt Jones is facing a felony drug charge in Arkansas. In all, the team has had 11 players arrested in the last two years.

But Del Rio said he disagreed with anyone wanting to lump Collier’s shooting in with some of the team’s other recent troubles.

“He was out last night, enjoying himself, having a good time, being responsible,” the coach said. “I take offense to people that insinuate and call that a lack of discipline or a lack of responsibility. There are no rules about being out on a Monday night before your day off the following day.


The 6-foot-7, 345-pound linemen was arrested Nov. 3 after officers found him asleep behind the wheel at a McDonald’s drive-thru window. Collier failed field sobriety tests and had a blood-alcohol level of .096, according to police. In Florida, it is illegal to drive with a blood-alcohol level of .08 or higher.

Collier was suspended two games and fined.

Why, when an athlete, or anyone, is on his deathbed, is there a need to sum up all the supposed errata of his life? Sports on My Mind and Sportaphile are all over this — it’s insensitive and more than just a little bit racist, as if black men, particularly black athletes, do not get to be victims of crimes without any incidents they have had brought back against them while they lie in hospital beds. The fact that Mike Florio at PFT is writing this in the context of the Jaguars having to clean up their house is absolutely disgusting. Collier getting shot has no business being the jumping off point for an analysis of a team’s collective yellow sheets.

Florio and crew usually dig up pretty good stuff most of the time, but the “Turd Watch” is a loathsome feature — and now it’s really gone beyond the pale.

We went through this with Sean Taylor — everyone jumped to conclusions about where he was, what he was doing, the kind of life he led — and judged him a thug, looked foolish doing so, and yet no one decided that it was even worth an apology to his family after he died trying to protect his home.

I don’t think we should hold our breath asking for apologies from anyone stupid enough to write about Collier’s off-field troubles or to use his lying in a hospital bed for an examination of his teammates.  It would be nice if there was at least a bit of respect for an innocent victim.


3 Responses

  1. I stopped listening to him a while back, but I wouldn’t be surprised if that asshat Cowherd was jumping on the “you reap what you sow” bandwagon. He did the same thing with Taylor’s death, and was less than remorseful when it turned out he was wrong. It’s just another example of racial profiling…

  2. This is indeed a tragic situation, and I hope that Richard does completely heal from the shooting and maybe even continue with his football career.
    However, that doesn’t hide the fact that this is yet another young, rich athlete that is out extremely late at night, at nightclubs, attracting (the wrong kind of) attention, indulging in various activities like women, alcohol, expensive cars, drugs, and weapons. Maybe Richard didn’t do all of these, but he was arrested within this past year with a BAC level over the legal limit.
    Richard should face the fact that he’s totally responsible for his actions. You don’t want to get shot or in trouble? Maybe you shouldn’t be out at 3 o’clock in the morning, hunting tail. During the season. After already getting busted for DWI.
    I hope he recovers. And I hope he’s suspended for two games and fined.

  3. So, wait: you want him suspended and fined FOR GETTING SHOT???

    What the fuck is your problem? Seriously, I’m asking. Yes, he has a DWI on his record. Does that mean he shouldn’t be allowed to go out at night and go to clubs like the rest of us? Attracting the wrong kind of attention doesn’t mean he has to be forced to be a damned shut-in.

    He’s responsible for his own actions — but he is NOT responsible for being in critical condition in a hospital bed.

    Good Lord.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: